RC vs PT slab comparison calculator
Compare a reinforced concrete flat slab with a post-tensioned one for your grid, loads and unit rates: thickness, concrete, rebar, strand, cost, weight and building height. These are scheme-stage figures, and every result is indicative.
| Indicative | RC slab | PT slab | PT vs RC |
|---|
Indicative only, not a design. These are scheme-stage estimates from published rules of thumb. Thickness, reinforcement and strand quantities depend on the full analysis: punching shear, deflection, crack control, fire, restraint, openings, transfer and the code your authority applies. Final sizes need a full design.
How the two systems compare in practice
| Aspect | RC flat slab | PT flat slab |
|---|---|---|
| Floor cycle | More rebar to fix per floor; formwork can be struck once the slab is strong enough and back-propped. | Less rebar to fix; tendons are placed and stressed once the concrete reaches transfer strength, which often lets formwork be released earlier. |
| Deflection control | Relies on depth and reinforcement; long-term creep and cracking govern longer spans. | Tendon drape balances part of the dead load, so long-term deflection is easier to control at a thinner section. |
| Openings flexibility | Openings and late cores are easier to add; trimming bars are needed. | Openings need to be planned around tendons and bands; late coring needs tendon scanning and a check. |
| Crack control | Cracks are expected and controlled by bar spacing and cover. | Precompression keeps much of the slab uncracked in service, which helps water-tightness and durability. |
| Slab depth and height | Deeper slabs add self-weight and floor-to-floor height. | Thinner, lighter slabs reduce loads on columns and foundations, and building height. |
How we calculate
Every number is indicative and comes from published scheme-stage guidance, simplified into transparent formulas.
1. Slab thickness
- ACI 318 / PTI basis. h = L / (r × k), where L is the longer span, r is the published span/depth ratio and k is our load adjustment. r = 30 (RC flat plate), 35 (RC with drop panels), 45 (PT flat plate) and 50 (PT with drop panels), from the preliminary sizing guidance in [2]. The RC value sits close to the ACI 318-19 Table 8.3.1.1 minimum of ln/30 for exterior panels without edge beams [4].
- Load adjustment k. k = 1 − 0.04 × (SDL + LL − 3.0), limited to 0.60 to 1.00. Published ratios apply to light loading (about 1.9 to 3.4 kPa superimposed) [2]. The 4% per kPa reduction is our simplification of how depth rises with load in the Concrete Centre tables [1][3].
- Eurocode 2 basis. Depths are interpolated by span and load from The Concrete Centre data: RC flat slabs from ECFE Table 3.7 (Table 3.8 for slabs with column heads or drops) [3], and PT flat slabs from Concrete Quarterly Figure 1 [1], with drop panels taken as 0.9 × the flat plate depth. The tables assume 1.5 kPa SDL, so we use an equivalent imposed load of LL + (SDL − 1.5).
- Thickness is rounded up to 10 mm, with a 200 mm minimum for both systems (the industry-standard minimum noted in [1]). Drop panels are taken as L/3 × L/3 on plan with a projection of h/2, rounded up to 25 mm. That adds projection/9 to the average thickness.
2. Quantities
- Concrete per m² = average thickness (m). Self-weight = 25 kN/m³ × average thickness.
- RC rebar (kg/m²) is interpolated from ECFE Tables 3.7 and 3.8 [3]. PT slab rebar (mesh, loose bars and anchorage bursting steel) is interpolated from Concrete Quarterly Figure 1 [1]. Both are UK Eurocode-practice rates; ACI designs in the Gulf can differ, so use the override fields if you have better figures.
- PT strand on the Eurocode 2 basis comes from Concrete Quarterly Figure 1 [1]. On the ACI basis we use load balancing in both directions. Balanced load w = 0.70 × (self-weight + SDL), drape a = h − 80 mm, and P = w L² / 8a per metre in each direction. Precompression is at least 0.86 MPa (ACI 318 minimum average precompression [4]). We assume 150 kN effective force per 15.2 mm strand and 1.102 kg/m, plus 5% for stressing tails and end zones.
3. Cost, weight and height
- Cost per m² = concrete m³ × concrete rate + rebar kg × rebar rate / 1000 + strand kg × PT rate + formwork rate. Totals = cost per m² × floor plate area × floors.
- Self-weight saved = (RC − PT self-weight) × total floor area, shown in tonnes (kN / 9.81) and as a percentage of the RC floor service load (self-weight + SDL + LL).
- Height saved = (RC thickness − PT thickness) × number of floors, for the same clear height.
- Not included: columns, walls, foundations, cores, programme, preliminaries, back-propping, design fees or the value of extra height or lettable area. In practice these often decide the choice.
When post-tensioning beats reinforced concrete
Post-tensioning puts a controlled compression into the slab and uses draped tendons to lift part of the dead load. The slab works more efficiently than a conventionally reinforced one, so the same span can be carried by a thinner, lighter floor with far less reinforcement to fix. The Concrete Centre puts the saving at about 20% of the concrete and 50% of the steel in a flat slab [1]. Whether that turns into a lower overall cost depends on the span, the load and local rates, which is what this calculator lets you test.
As general guidance, PT tends to pay back when one or more of these apply:
- Spans of roughly 8 m and above. RC flat slabs get deep and heavy beyond 8 to 9 m, while PT flat slabs stay economical to about 12 to 13 m [3].
- Height matters. In a tower, the slab depth saved on every floor adds up to less façade, lower overall height, or room for extra floors within a height limit.
- Columns and foundations are significant. Lighter slabs reduce column loads and piling, which this slab-only cost does not count.
- Programme is tight. Less rebar per floor and early stressing can shorten the floor cycle.
- Deflection or cracking is sensitive, for example long spans under glazing, podium decks or transfer slabs.
RC tends to stay competitive on short, regular grids (around 6 to 7 m), on floors with many late openings, and on small jobs where PT mobilisation and stressing costs are spread over little area.
Typical economic span ranges
Published scheme-design guidance gives these broad ranges for regular grids and normal building loads. They are general guidance, not limits:
| System | Usual economic span | Rule-of-thumb span/depth |
|---|---|---|
| RC flat slab | About 5 to 9 m, commonly used up to 12 m [3] | About L/30 flat plate, L/35 with drops [2] |
| PT flat slab | Up to about 12 to 13 m [3] | About L/45 flat plate, L/50 with drops, light loading [2] |
| PT one-way slab on PT band beams | Longer spans, up to about 18 m [3] | Beams about L/20 to L/30 [2] |
On grids of around 7.5 to 9 m the choice is often close, so it is worth running both systems with your own rates. Car parks, podiums and offices with longer spans usually favour PT. The best answer for a given building comes from comparing both systems on the actual grid, loads and approval route.
What the cost figure does and does not show
The cost row compares the slab only: concrete, reinforcement, strand and formwork. On short spans PT can come out slightly dearer on that basis. Its savings show up elsewhere: smaller column and foundation loads, less building height and façade, a faster floor cycle and better crack and deflection control. The weight and height rows give you a feel for those effects, but they are not priced. If the slab-only cost is within a few per cent either way, those wider savings usually decide.
The default AED rates are example rates for illustration, not market data. Enter current rates from your own quotations for concrete, rebar, PT and formwork before drawing any conclusion.
Reading the results
- Use the longer span of the typical bay. Rectangular panels are sized on the longer span.
- SDL covers finishes, screed, services, ceilings and partitions. Live load comes from the occupancy (for example about 2 kPa for residential and 2.5 to 5 kPa for offices, depending on the code and the client brief).
- The design basis switch changes only the span/depth source. ACI 318 with PTI-style ratios is common in the Gulf; the Eurocode 2 option uses UK Concrete Centre data, which assumes UK fire, cover and loading practice.
- If the slab is set by the 200 mm minimum, PT is not using its full span capacity, so a wider grid may make better use of it.
For a quick depth check on a single system, including drop panels and band beams, use our PT slab thickness calculator. For the technical background, see post-tensioned vs reinforced concrete slabs in the UAE and bonded vs unbonded post-tensioning.
Sources
Published guidance we used for the rules of thumb above, consulted on 13 November 2026. The numbers are paraphrased and simplified for scheme-stage use; they are not quoted design values.
- The Concrete Centre / J. Burridge, Concrete Quarterly, Spring 2020: “High tension: an introduction to specifying post-tensioned slabs”, Figure 1: span-to-depth ratios and rates for PT flat slabs
- Z. Xia, STRUCTURE / Structural Engineer magazine, October 2008: “Efficient floor framing systems: preliminary sizing of post-tensioned floors” (span/depth about 45 PT and 30 RC flat plates, 50 and 35 with drop panels; wide shallow beams 1/4 to 1/5 of spacing, 2.0 to 2.5 × slab depth; beams about L/28)
- C. H. Goodchild, R. M. Webster and K. S. Elliott, The Concrete Centre, 2009: Economic Concrete Frame Elements to Eurocode 2, Tables 3.7 and 3.8 (RC flat slabs)
- American Concrete Institute: ACI 318-19 Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete: Table 8.3.1.1 (minimum thickness of nonprestressed two-way slabs), 8.2.4 (drop panels), 8.6.2.1 (average precompression of at least 0.9 MPa), 22.6.5 (two-way shear strength)
Part of our tools and PT design guides. Codes are referred to by clause where we are confident of the reference; always check the edition and national annex adopted for your project.
Questions we are asked about this.
Is post-tensioning cheaper than reinforced concrete?
It depends on span, load and local rates. On slab materials alone, PT is often close to RC on short grids and cheaper on longer spans. Its bigger savings usually come from lighter columns and foundations, less building height and a faster floor cycle, which a slab-only comparison does not price. Use the calculator with current rates, then ask us for a comparison on your actual grid.
How much thinner is a PT slab than an RC slab?
Published guidance puts a PT flat plate at about span/45 and an RC flat plate at about span/30 for light loading, so for an 8 m span that is roughly 200 mm against 270 to 280 mm. Heavier loads, edge panels, punching shear and fire requirements all change this, and 200 mm is a common practical minimum.
Are the AED unit rates in the calculator market prices?
No. They are example rates so the calculator works out of the box. Material and labour prices change often and vary by project and contract, so enter current rates from your own quotations for concrete, rebar, PT and formwork.
Why does the calculator offer ACI 318 and Eurocode 2 options?
The two codes lead to different scheme-stage depths. The ACI option uses span/depth ratios from PTI-based guidance, adjusted for load. The Eurocode 2 option interpolates Concrete Centre tables prepared for UK practice. Comparing both shows how sensitive the answer is to the design basis.
Can I use these results for tender or authority submission?
No. The results are indicative scheme-stage estimates. A PT slab needs a full design covering load balancing, stresses, deflection, punching shear, fire, restraint, openings and detailing to the code your authority applies. Send us your plans and we can review them or prepare the preliminary or full PT design.
Does the comparison include columns and foundations?
Not in the cost. The calculator shows the slab self-weight saved in tonnes and as a share of the floor service load, which gives a feel for the reduction in column and foundation loads. Pricing those savings needs the structural scheme.
Send the drawings. Get an answer from our engineers.
WhatsApp or email the architectural or structural set, the location and what you need. The reply comes from the engineers who will do the work, with a proposed scope and programme.
- +971 52 118 2569
- Telephone
- +971 52 118 2569
- Office
- Al Warqa 1, Dubai, UAE
- Hours
- Sunday – Thursday, 09:00 – 18:00 GST
