1. Home
  2. Resources
  3. Punching shear in PT slabs
PT design guide  ·  Iron Axis engineering team

Punching shear in post-tensioned slabs: ACI 318 vs Eurocode 2

Punching at the column is the failure mode that most often decides the thickness of a PT flat slab. How ACI 318-19 and Eurocode 2 treat it, what precompression and inclined tendons contribute, and when shear studs are needed.

Design codes
ACI 318 · Eurocode 2 · PTI
Software
RAM Concept · AutoCAD · Revit
S-820 Video

Watch: a short explainer

Punching Shear in PT Slabs: What Prestress Adds

What prestress contributes to punching shear capacity in a PT slab, and what still has to be checked at the columns.

Want the numbers for your own column? Our punching shear calculator runs ACI 318-19 and Eurocode 2 side by side for interior, edge and corner columns, with a printable report.

Punching shear is a brittle failure in which the column pushes through the slab along a truncated cone or pyramid. In post-tensioned flat slabs it often sets the minimum slab thickness, the column size or the need for drop panels and shear reinforcement. Precompression helps, and tendons draped over the column add an upward component that reduces the net shear. The two main codes in the region, ACI 318-19 (adopted in Saudi Arabia through SBC 304 and widely used in the UAE) and EN 1992-1-1, handle these effects differently.

Control perimeters

Punching shear control perimeters, ACI 318 and Eurocode 2columnACI: b0 at d/2 (square corners)EC2: u1 at 2d (rounded corners)banded tendons through column
ACI 318 checks a perimeter at d/2 from the column face; Eurocode 2 uses a basic control perimeter at 2d with rounded corners.

ACI 318-19 checks a critical section b0 at d/2 from the column face, with straight sides and square corners (§22.6.4). EN 1992-1-1 checks a basic control perimeter u1 at 2d from the loaded area, with rounded corners (§6.4.2), plus a check of maximum shear at the column face u0. Because the perimeters and the stress expressions differ, the stresses from the two codes cannot be compared directly; only the final capacities can.

ACI 318-19 for prestressed slabs

For two-way prestressed slabs meeting the conditions of §22.6.5.5 (no column closer to a discontinuous edge than four slab thicknesses, f'c used in the root not more than 35 MPa, fpc in each direction between 0.9 and 3.5 MPa):

vc = βp λ √f'c + 0.3 fpc + Vp / (b0 d)    (MPa)
βp = lesser of 0.29 and 0.083(αs d / b0 + 1.5)

Here fpc is the average precompression in the two directions, αs is 40, 30 and 20 for interior, edge and corner columns, and Vp is the vertical component of the effective prestress crossing the critical section. Where the conditions are not met, the slab is treated with the nonprestressed expressions of §22.6.5.2 (the least of 0.33λ√f'c, the aspect-ratio and perimeter expressions, with the size effect factor λs), without the precompression term.

Unbalanced moment is transferred partly by flexure and partly by eccentric shear (γvMsc, §8.4.4.2), so the maximum stress at the critical section is vu = Vu/(b0d) + γvMscc/Jc. The design check is vu ≤ φvc with φ = 0.75.

Eurocode 2

vRd,c = CRd,c k (100 ρl fck)1/3 + k1 σcp ≥ vmin + k1 σcp
CRd,c = 0.18/γc,   k = 1 + √(200/d) ≤ 2.0,   ρl = √(ρly ρlz) ≤ 0.02,   k1 = 0.1

(EN 1992-1-1 §6.4.4, recommended values; check the National Annex.) The applied stress is vEd = βVEd/(u1d), where β allows for moment transfer; the simplified values in §6.4.3(6) are 1.15 for interior, 1.4 for edge and 1.5 for corner columns in braced frames with similar adjacent spans. Inclined tendons crossing the control section give a favourable vertical component, Vpd, that can be deducted from VEd (§6.4.3(2) and note). Bonded tendons can also count towards ρl in some interpretations; check how the National Annex and your firm treat it.

Shear reinforcement

Headed shear studs are the most common punching reinforcement in PT slabs because the rails sit easily between tendons. In ACI 318-19 (§22.6.6 and §22.6.8) the concrete contribution with headed studs is limited to about 0.25λ√f'c (MPa) and the maximum nominal stress to about 0.66√f'c; studs must extend until the stress on an outer critical section falls below the concrete-only limit, typically 0.17λ√f'c at d/2 outside the outermost studs. In EN 1992-1-1 (§6.4.5, eq. 6.52):

vRd,cs = 0.75 vRd,c + 1.5 (d/sr) Asw fywd,ef sinα / (u1 d),    fywd,ef = 250 + 0.25d ≤ fywd (MPa)

with a maximum at the column face vEd,0 ≤ vRd,max, and the outer perimeter uout found where shear reinforcement is no longer required. Many stud systems hold European Technical Assessments that permit higher capacities than eq. 6.52; their documents then govern the design.

Indicative values. The ACI stud limits (0.25√f'c, 0.66√f'c, 0.17√f'c) are quoted as we understand ACI 318-19 Chapter 22. Check the clause and the λs and φ factors for your edition, and use the stud supplier's approval for proprietary systems.

Worked comparison (illustrative)

Interior column 600 × 600 mm, slab 250 mm, d = 210 mm, f'c = 40 MPa (cylinder), fpc = 1.5 MPa, ignore Vp.

ACI 318-19: b0 = 4 × (600 + 210) = 3,240 mm. αsd/b0 + 1.5 = 40 × 210/3240 + 1.5 = 4.09, so 0.083 × 4.09 = 0.34 and βp = 0.29. The root uses f'c limited to 35 MPa:

vc = 0.29 × √35 + 0.3 × 1.5 = 1.72 + 0.45 = 2.17 MPa
φVc = 0.75 × 2.17 × 3240 × 210 / 1000 ≈ 1,107 kN

EN 1992-1-1: fck = 40 MPa, γc = 1.5, k = 1 + √(200/210) = 1.976, ρl = 0.5%, σcp = 1.5 MPa. u1 = 4 × 600 + 2π × 2 × 210 = 5,039 mm.

vRd,c = 0.12 × 1.976 × (100 × 0.005 × 40)1/3 + 0.1 × 1.5 = 0.12 × 1.976 × 2.71 + 0.15 ≈ 0.79 MPa
VRd,c = 0.79 × 5039 × 210 / 1000 ≈ 836 kN (before dividing VEd by β = 1.15)

The ACI and Eurocode figures are not directly comparable: the load factors (1.2D + 1.6L against 1.35G + 1.5Q), the material factors, the moment-transfer method and the perimeter all differ. The example shows the steps, not which code is more generous. In both codes, the inclined component of the tendons over the column (Vp or Vpd) often adds substantially, which is a good reason to keep banded tendons passing through or close to the column.

Practical points

  • Openings within about 4h (ACI §22.6.4.3) or 6d (EC2 §6.4.2(3)) of the column reduce the perimeter. See openings and penetrations.
  • Edge and corner columns usually govern; check them with the actual unbalanced moment.
  • Only tendons within a defined distance of the column contribute to Vp; check the code definition.
  • Punching interacts with drift in seismic design; see seismic design of PT slabs.
  • Transfer slabs and heavily loaded podiums often need drop panels or column capitals; see PT transfer slabs and beams.

Summary

Punching shear: ACI 318-19 vs EN 1992-1-1
ItemACI 318-19EN 1992-1-1
Control perimeterb0 at d/2, square corners (§22.6.4)u1 at 2d, rounded corners (§6.4.2)
Concrete strength termβpλ√f'c, βp ≤ 0.29, f'c ≤ 35 MPa in rootCRd,ck(100ρlfck)1/3
Precompression term0.3 fpc, fpc 0.9–3.5 MPa0.1 σcp
Inclined tendonsVp/(b0d) addedVpd deducted from VEd
Moment transferγvMscc/Jcβ factor (1.15/1.4/1.5 simplified)
Studsvc ≤ 0.25√f'c, vn ≤ 0.66√f'c (indicative)Eq. 6.52 or product ETA

Our PT design review and preliminary PT design support services include punching checks at every column.

Part of our PT design guides. Codes are referred to by clause where we are confident of the reference, and coefficients marked indicative should be checked against the code text; always check the edition and national annex adopted for your project. Worked examples are illustrative, not designs.

S-416 FAQ

Questions we are asked about this.

Does post-tensioning increase punching shear capacity?

Yes. ACI 318-19 adds 0.3fpc and the vertical tendon component Vp to the concrete stress, and Eurocode 2 adds 0.1σcp and lets the inclined tendon component reduce the design shear.

Why can ACI and Eurocode punching stresses not be compared directly?

They use different control perimeters (d/2 against 2d), different load and material factors and different moment-transfer methods. Only the overall capacity checks are comparable.

What is Vp in punching shear?

The vertical component of the effective prestress force in the tendons crossing the critical section. Tendons draped over the column push upwards and reduce the net shear.

When are shear studs needed in a PT slab?

When the factored shear stress exceeds the concrete capacity, when seismic drift compatibility requires them, or when a thinner slab is preferred to drop panels.

Is there an upper limit on precompression for punching?

ACI 318-19 uses fpc only between 0.9 and 3.5 MPa in the prestressed punching expression, so additional precompression above 3.5 MPa gives no further credit.

Do openings near columns affect punching?

Yes. Part of the control perimeter within the shadow of an opening near the column is ignored in both codes, which can reduce capacity significantly.

S-901 Contact

Send the drawings. Get an answer from our engineers.

WhatsApp or email the architectural or structural set, the location and what you need. The reply comes from the engineers who will do the work, with a proposed scope and programme.

Office
Al Warqa 1, Dubai, UAE
Hours
Sunday – Thursday, 09:00 – 18:00 GST